| In
December of 2006, the Center for Intercultural Organizing—with
assistance from our Portland State University "Politics
of Immigration" Capstone class—analyzed three
sources of population data, including the Urban Institute
Study, A
Profile of the Foreign-Born in the Portland, Oregon
Tri-County Area based on figures from
the 2000 U.S. Census, the 2005
American Community Survey, and data obtained
from U.S.
Citizenship and Immigration Services (2005).
We
found that there is presently a lack of accurate, detailed,
and comprehensive demographic information for Portland's
immigrant and refugee communities. Accurate demographic
data would be a valuable asset for policymakers. Such
information would enable the city to direct its services
and resources where they are most needed, particularly
those which are culturally specific like translation
services. It would also enable the city government to
identify particular groups of immigrants and refugees
and take them into account in decision making processes.
Population
data emanating from the federal government are problematic
in several ways. The data readily available to the public
combines Portland into larger geographical areas. U.S.
Citizenship and Immigration Services provides data for
the entire state of Oregon and the Portland metro region.
The Urban Institute Study published data for the Portland
tri-county area, which has a total population of approximately
1.5 million. The American Community Survey includes
Portland in a metropolitan statistical area that also
contains the cities of Beaverton and Vancouver. Federal
population data are usually out of date by the time
they reach the public, as it takes a lot of time to
compile statistics for the entire country.
The
U.S. Census is not well-suited to detect diverse immigrant
and refugee populations. It relies heavily on race categories
and lumps certain groups together. Counting undocumented
immigrants is likewise problematic. It is a reasonable
supposition that undocumented immigrants are reluctant
to participate in government surveys for fear of legal
consequences, especially given the political climate
presently surrounding the issue of immigration.
In
addition, demographics on immigrants may inadvertently
focus on visible populations rather than actual numbers
of all immigrants. They may not take into account those
that come from countries and cultures that do not stand
out through customs and language. There are likely areas
in Portland where there are large numbers of immigrants
who fit this category. It is much easier to determine
refugee demographics because of their association with
resettlement and social service agencies.
In
light of these deficiencies, we recommend that the City
of Portland find resources to conduct appropriate demographic
research in order to gain an accurate understanding
of its immigrant and refugee population. By utilizing
existing resources, like the Portland State University
Population Research Center, the city could better assess
the drill down demographic characteristics of individual
neighborhoods and populations. A comprehensive and accurate
depiction of Portland’s newcomer populations would enable
policy leaders to dispense resources more efficiently
and serve its residents more effectively. |